Has anybody measured intake air temp before and after? The primary purpose of a "cold air intake" is to lower the IAT so you get a more dense air charge and theoretically, more oxygen to the engine. That's why boosted engines are intercooled, to bring down the IATs. Increased flow is worthless if you're just sucking more hot air. In addition, more flow in = more flow out. A CAI by itself only separates you from your hard earned cash, to see any effective gains you'll need to address flow out and fueling....in other words, headers and a tune.
I've seen this same debate over CAIs on Chargers/Challies. The OEM air box on my Scat runs 7-10* above ambient in clean air. No CAI, no Hellcat air box mod, just the OEM box with an OEM filter. Most of these CAIs pull air out of the engine compartment where everything gets heat soaked, especially on the LX cars. The only CAI that makes any difference at all (maybe 2-3*) is the Legmaker that routes the filter out of the engine compartment and down behind the L/F headlight.
Almost everything I've seen on the market for trucks these days pulls air out of the engine compartment to some degree, with the exception of maybe the Vararam. The last real CAI I saw on a full size truck was the old Scotty II we used to run in the 2nd Gen diesel days. Long filter and an "air box" that required a 4" hole in the firewall to pull air from the low pressure area at the base of the windshield, right under the plastic cowl.