My system is IMO well balanced volume-wise so I’ll compare my sound and specs to your option.I just wrapped up a conversation with Crutchfield. I'm curious to see what the experts on here think of this plan.
Their recommendation is as follows:
Direct dash replacement with Infinity Reference REF-3032cfx 3-1/2" 2-way car speakers
Direct 4 door replacements with PowerBass L2-692T 6"x9" 2-way car speakers — designed to replace 2-ohm factory speakers
Note: I wish we had the Ram stock speaker sensitivity ratings but we don’t. Half impedance replacement speakers (4 vs 8 ohm as in the dash) need to be approx -3dB lower sensitivity to be equal volume at same power. Double impedance speakers (4 vs 2 as in our doors) need +3 dB to sound the same. On to the math and specifications!
6x9s
JL C2 6x9s = 4 ohm w/ 93 dB sensitivity (at 1W)
PowerBass L2 6x9s = 2 ohm w/ 89 dB sensitivity (at 1W).
Therefore those 6x9s are really close, maybe a tiny bit quieter, than my JLs.
3.5s:
JL C2 3.5s = 4 ohm w/ 86 dB (at 2.83 W)
Infinity 3032s = 3 ohm w/ 91 dB (at 2.83 W)
Not only lower impedance but also higher sensitivity. Therefore I would estimate the Infinity speakers to be about “two volume clicks” (~6 dB) louder than my 3.5s
Ignoring whether you actually like the sound of those speakers, in the end I would expect that proposed system to have louder 3.5s than mine, which may sound great to you or it may be too much... at this point we enter relativity-land and subjectivity-land.
Importantly I was able to listen to the JLs locally and the one thing I knew was I loved their sound. Good luck, hope this thought process helps you predict how it will sound so you can order something that will work.