Been following this thread with interest. I'm shortly going to be a first time truck owner....and I've ordered a '22 Rebel, hahaha ! At least I am now mentally getting prepared for 15mpg on average from reading this thread. I was probably hoping for 18mpg but that does look like wishful thinking from what I read here. Current vehicle is a '07 Outback ( 2.5L 4 cylinder turbo ). It gets 22mpg on Premium in mixed driving. By mixed I mean probably 30% urban driving, but not "stop and go gridlock" either.
I'm estimating anywhere from $500 to $750 per year more gas costs with the truck, depending obviously on gas prices and how much I drive.
I had been thinking I'd sell the Subaru to help pay off the truck ( I'm in the Pacific NW which is "Subaru country", so I'd find a market for it. Also I recently had major work done on it, I threw a rod and wound up putting a brand new short block in it and getting the heads and valves machined. Along with a recent new clutch & timing belt it's almost new under the hood! ), however, I'm beginning to think I should hang onto it and use it for a "grocery getter" / short errands to town, and use the truck for "truck stuff" - hiking / camping trips, going to the woods for firewood, longer road trips etc. I could also use the Subaru for the kids to learn to drive in, and that way they'll learn to drive a stick shift
Although whether or not I should start them off in a 240hp Subaru is another story, it's got a lot of get up and go !