Fair enough. I reckon I was probably more heavy on the gas pedal those first few miles, too. I checked the mileage on 89 for the period from 3000 (approx) on the odometer going forward.
On 89, after 3000 miles of break-in, I did 4065 miles and used 269 gallons. That is 15.1 MPG. Same as what I have been getting since I switched to 87.
I addressed those questions in my first post.
Like I said, when the onboard computer is shown to be off, and by varying amounts, any conclusions drawn based on what it says are a waste of breath. It's not consistently off by 1MPG. If it were, then maybe you could watch it and draw some conclusions. But, when it's spot-on at one fill-up and off by 2 MPG the next fill-up and off by 1 MPG the next and then 1.5, and then spot-on again, looking at what it says for individual fill-ups is useless.
And, even if you hand-calculated, comparing the results of 3 or 4 or 5 individual fill-ups is also not a basis for any conclusions that are strongly supported. The variables at each fill-up are too great. Did you fill to the same level? Was the truck perfectly level each time? And then, how much of the previous gas was still left in the tank, so what was the real octane of the gas you were driving with?
When you put those two things together, any conclusions drawn are about as valid as me looking out my window right now and saying the sky is grey and grass is brown. The conclusion may be perfectly correct - there's just no actual proof.