Is your truck a 4WD? I've tried the two bag method and an Oil Udder, and neither has been effective for me. I can catch the initial mess, but I can barely squeeze the filter (on its side) through the lines when removing it...the Oil Udder just trapped excess oil and dumped it all out at once when I tried to work it out of that little cavity.
It's the complete opposite experience of the Fumoto, which makes oil draining a surgical procedure
Yes my 2022 Limited is 4x4.
I have no problem with the oil udder attached to a tube.
I start to spin the filter once the filter is attached (magnet) to the bottom of the filter. Soon as oil starts coming off the sides of the filter I just let it sit for a couple of minutes and eventually unscrew it into the oil udder and bend an electrical cable and take it right down
Not sure how you are trapping oil, sounds like you might of not used it correctly?
You are suppose to connect a pvc tube to the bottom of the oil udder. You only put the cap on for storage.
Sounds like you were changing it with the cap on, which yeah is just going to collect oil and make a mess.
You also talk about the Fumoto, but that's just for the drain plug not filter?
I make an aluminum foil boat (funnel) and place it on the horizontal bar to let it go into the pan. In theory I could just hold a funnel up if I wanted but a Fumoto valve would make the drain plug easier but I personally don't mind it.
If you think these are bad look at my what I need to do on my wife's SUV oil filter.
GMC Acadia Engine Oil Change & Filter Replacement Guide - 3.6L LLT V6 Motor - 2009 To 2016 Model Years - Picture Illustrated Automotive Maintenance DIY Instructions
It's a lot smaller in there then it looks also, you can't even turn your hand around once you put it down into the death trap and it's not possible to catch the oil it drains over everything below it.