ohh i was confused because the thread is titled for commuter 2.0 not 2.5 Performance lol
honestly, IF you do go wheel a lot and enjoy driving fast on the trails and "accidentally" hitting those bumps and whoops at speed, the 2.5 Performance will be the best bang for the buck you can get, BUT it seems like that's not your use case so the next best is the 2.0 Commuter. BUT if you can stretch your budget and run trails a lot, you will appreciate it. Those Performance shocks do have more travel than stock King or Fox 2.5, and has better valving when on dirt to prevent bucking around in the rear and bottoming out in the front. Those are going to be the best kit you can get performance wise. No other kit will come close to that, not even my Fox 2.5 DSC PE.
For your tires and wheels, Methods was running a sale a few weeks back (unfortunately you just missed it) and tbh Method is gonna be the best choice to get for wheels as it's strong and yet lightweight enough and affordable enough. Tires pricing is everywhere these days. I'd say just go with Wildpeak AT4. Those are some good combos that I personally run and not too expensive.
View attachment 182760
(Obviously, pricing reflected set of 5, going off what was posted MSRP in April 2023. Talk to a few shops, usually shops can get these for less than posted MSRP)
Labor is around what we charge at our shop down in SoCal, without the homie hookup (like $60 difference or so). All that said, what I'm saying is, if you hit trails a lot and enjoy going fast, postpone the install and purchase and save up some more. Don't rush it. If you don't hit the trails a lot then it's okay for 2.0 Commuter, since it's more valved for commuting and occasional offroad (hence, "commuter" name)
So for my personal truck:
First off,
reason why I did this combo is simply because Kings were on national backorder at the time when I ordered my parts in 2022. I ordered my truck on June 30th, 2022 and started to order parts on July 1, 2022. With the goal of completing the built by 12/31/2022 to be ready for Alaska in summer 2023, I wanted to have at least 6 months before the big trip to dial in and dry run everything. Having an idea of how the auto industry was at the time of order, I estimated Kings would take around 12 months of lead time BEFORE getting to Carli, while Fox I estimated lead time of up to 6 months. (I do these installs so I estimate based on the time frame between we order parts for customers and parts actually show up). That'd be not enough time to meet my deadline of 12/31/2022 to complete the build.
Then my estimate was right on. Truck arrived at my door November 8th, 2022, Fox shocks arrived a week or two after. I installed everything over Thanksgiving weekend when the shop was closed. IF there was no national backorder, I'd gone Carli Performance Pack instead.
Now, experience with the Fox 2.5 DSC PE and Carli components. This is gonna be a two part answer:
Fox 2.5 DSC PE:
The valving on these are pretty on par with non-Carli Kings, but I do like the dual speed compression adjustability. This allows me to have on-road and off-road mode on my shock package. Had I went kings, I'd swap out the reservoir from King's mid-speed to Fox's DSC resi (yes, they do work like that). With my on-road settings, when I go up the mountains with all the gears, I can still overtake regular traffics in corners without losing traction or feel like I'm going to top over. It is planted and controlled. With my off-road settings, I can hit Mojave desert going 50-60MPH, skipping through the whoops at no problem at all. The shocks never overheated and the strokes kept up with the terrain, and soaked up the small jumps pretty well. I've never bottomed out even with full overlanding weight.
HOWEVER, the droop on these are not as good as the Carli Performance Kings (i think Carli has an inch or so more). That became an issue when Crawling or when hitting big jumps and whoops. More droop means your tires touch the ground earlier, and your shocks got more travel to absorb the impact of landing. Just like for men, every inch counts.
Carli Components:
The UCA and other components are not much to report about, other than they are designed and manufactured to do their jobs for hitting desert and the trails.
Keep in mind, if you go 2.0 Commuter and opt for UCA, that unlocks more droop for you and therefore, requires you to run their extended brake lines (i just thought of that so i put it here). The components are built tough with proper bushing materials and design, so they CAN take a lot of abuse. For my UCA, I personally grease them every other oil change (if I don't go out a lot) or every oil change (if that 5k mile period saw a lot of dirt).
The rear springs, however, are something to rave about. With the tender spring design, it handles the camper+drawer+gear weight perfectly. The rear doesn't sag with all the weight, and the dual rated springs still perform even with all that weight. With ~100lb less weight in the bed (prior to CAMPER but with bed rack and roof tent), the handling and ride characteristics are very similar. Those are the springs that can handle the weight!
Verdict:
Mine setup is not the #1 ideal setup I'd go with, but given the constrains at the time of ordering, it is the second best that one can get off the shelf. Of course, the absolute best off-the-shelf setup, at least for me who has the know-how and the tools, would be Carli King + Fox Resi that offers more travel AND dual speed adjustment. Or, if I don't have to stick with off-the-shelf systems, would be custom tuned Thuren Kings (since Thuren doesn't touch Fox anymore)
BUT, aside from (compared to Carli Kings') not-so-much droop, Fox 2.5 DSC + Carli components is probably the best of both worlds factoring in on and offroad performance. Carli Performance is GREAT for offroad, but can be slight harsher ride on pavement. The Fox 2.5 DSC gives you the ability to tune it on how you want it to be for that optimal ride quality.
I would recommend if you want to go that route.
View attachment 182769
(Pricing as of 2022)