I have had the McGard's in the past and they are no better than what's on Amazon. They rusted no different. The ones I bought have a black zinc e-plating and are then painted. I am not expecting a miracle but they held up without a scratch when they were put on.Most of the cheaper ones on Amazon are just painted. And the paint gets messed up the first time you put a wrench on them. I second Malodave's recommendation and get the McGard's.
Yep...they'll all work well and no better or worse than the Amazon lug nuts I posted.I used the McGard cone seat bulge lug nuts part 64074 set of 4. For me, they work well.
My experience with them is different. It's okay if you disagree, and if you're happy with the cheapie painted lug nuts, more power to you. I haven't had the same experience with them, and the McGard lug nuts held up great for the two and a half years they were on my Rebel. The $30 painted lug nuts started rusting within a month of installing them.I have had the McGard's in the past and they are no better than what's on Amazon. They rusted no different. The ones I bought have a black zinc e-plating and are then painted. I am not expecting a miracle but they held up without a scratch when they were put on.
Understood...however, the ones I bought are not just painted lug nuts. They are zinc e-coated and then painted so an extra level of protection against rust. I just put mine on last week, so we'll see how well they hold up. I am impressed with the quality appearance and construction of the ones I purchased. I have had McGard in the past on several vehicles and everyone had rust issues.My experience with them is different. It's okay if you disagree, and if you're happy with the cheapie painted lug nuts, more power to you. I haven't had the same experience with them, and the McGard lug nuts held up great for the two and a half years they were on my Rebel. The $30 painted lug nuts started rusting within a month of installing them.
I'm a little dubious about the lug nuts you linked because it lists the material as steel, and the metal type as aluminum...Understood...however, the ones I bought are not just painted lug nuts. They are zinc e-coated and then painted so an extra level of protection against rust. I just put mine on last week, so we'll see how well they hold up. I am impressed with the quality appearance and construction of the ones I purchased. I have had McGard in the past on several vehicles and everyone had rust issues.
I contacted the seller...mistake. Solid high strength steel eCoated and then painted. I am not the only one who has purchased these as is VERY happy.I'm a little dubious about the lug nuts you linked because it lists the material as steel, and the metal type as aluminum...
You'd think they would fix their description if it was a mistake, especially since you asked them about it. Makes me think that English isn't their first language. That doesn't mean they're not a good product I guess.I contacted the seller...mistake. Solid high strength steel eCoated and then painted. I am not the only one who has purchased these as is VERY happy.
Time will tell regarding how well they hold upYou'd think they would fix their description if it was a mistake, especially since you asked them about it. Makes me think that English isn't their first language. That doesn't mean they're not a good product I guess.
I've just not had good luck with any of the cheaper lug nuts I've tried. But I've only tried less than a handful. There are a few reviews of people complaining about them rusting over time. Sounds like it's not an issue for you though. I'm glad you found something that works for you, and if they're as good as you say they're definitely a much less expensive alternative to the McGards. Thanks for the info on them.![]()
You don't know how Amazon works. I sell stuff on there and they control what is on their site. Trying to get anything changed is time consuming and a struggle. Most of the time it is just a waste of time.You'd think they would fix their description if it was a mistake, especially since you asked them about it. Makes me think that English isn't their first language. That doesn't mean they're not a good product I guess.
I've just not had good luck with any of the cheaper lug nuts I've tried. But I've only tried less than a handful. There are a few reviews of people complaining about them rusting over time. Sounds like it's not an issue for you though. I'm glad you found something that works for you, and if they're as good as you say they're definitely a much less expensive alternative to the McGards. Thanks for the info on them.![]()
You're right, I don't know how selling on Amazon works. I've sold things on ebay and assumed Amazon wouldn't be much different, as far as fixing a description in a listing. Thanks for clearing that up. However, as a seller, I would want to make sure a mistake like that gets fixed. It's definitely something that would affect my buying decision, so it wouldn't be a waste of time in my opinion.You don't know how Amazon works. I sell stuff on there and they control what is on their site. Trying to get anything changed is time consuming and a struggle. Most of the time it is just a waste of time.
Sent from my SM-G988U using Tapatalk
How did these hold up? Looking to purchase a set