Those mpg numbers sound pretty good. I usually average between 17-19mpg with my hemi, commuting back and forth to work. So I would think 27+ could be doable for me with the eco d. I would love to find a eco diesel with the 33 gallon tank. That would save me even more trips to the gas station. Doing a search, I can't find that combo anywhere near me.
Taking mpg out of the equation. As far as driving impressions, do you prefer driving one over the other, as far as hemi vs ed? Is there much difference, or pros and cons to each? Or would you say they are comparable enough where it's basically a coin toss.
I drive a minimum of 60 miles per day, so this answer takes that into account. I still believe that our driving situation will dictate what to get. If a lot of short, low mileage trips are what you do, then it will cause the diesel to need a lot of regens to clean the dpf (burning more fuel in the process).
The hemi had decent power when passing people, but overall, caused me to baby it to get the mpg numbers I got. The 15.2mpg I mentioned was babying it with 33” tires. I did like the simplicity of the hemi and the fact that I didn’t have to add any additives to the fuel during fillups. I have concerns about the longevity of the diesel engine, and it’s a guarantee that emissions components will eventually fail. However, the hemi engine has it’s own set of problems and makes long term reliability (of the engine itself, not associated control components) a wash.
I like the diesel a lot more now that I added a tuner to it. I don’t have to baby it like I did the hemi to get good MPG numbers. It felt slower before the tuner, but now feels just as fast as the hemi when doing highway speed pulls to pass vehicles.
People will complain that maintenance costs more than the hemi, and that’s simply not true if using aftermarket filters/oil. The exception to this is the diesel fuel filter cost is higher b/c the hemi doesn’t have a fuel filter- it has a integrated strainer sock in the fuel pump.
I love forced induction vehicles for everyday driving, so I love the on-road manners of the ecodiesel. I don’t like the tuning of the engine and trans for the hemi. It feels wrong to me.
Overall, it depends on your intended use. Neither is a perfect solution. To me, the ecodiesel edges ahead because I hate paying for fuel. However, that will bite me later if I keep the truck past 150k miles with a $4k dpf replacement and potential egr replacement. It’s pretty close to a wash if looking at it from a long term perspective.