Okay so this forum is the first ive heard of catch cans and i get the benefits. But could someone explain what happens to all that oil that gets into the crankcase? People are saying they are getting a couple ounces per oil change, it cant just collect in there are you would eventually have a quart or more in there, so does most of it get burned off or released out somewhere? dont know much about them or crankcases, trying to learn though. Also would FCA try to use them against you in a warranty claim? Thanks guys.
I presume you mean cylinders, as the oil originates from the crankcase and is intended to mostly stay there or things would very quickly get unpleasant for the pushrods.
Watch the videos above; the system is designed to take excess pressure built up in the crankcase and vent that pressure along with minute amounts of oil. This used to be done to atmosphere,but dumping oil to the atmosphere was not exactly friendly to the grass, so now it is dumped into the intake so the heat and combustion of the engine combined with the catalytic converter converts it into a much more environmentally friendly exhaust product.
In a nutshell, the Catch Can removes the need for the engine to perform this additional activity, at the cost of added weight and needing to empty and
PROPERLY dispose of the oil multiple times in between changes (shame on any of you that just dump this oil to get rid of it).
Other then the aforementioned weight and maintenance of the Can itself, there is no detrimental effects to having one. The major controversy is if there is any significant benefit to having one in an engine already designed from the start for this type of PCV system, but there is no unbiased studies and research to say either way. On the one hand, you have the engine manufacturers looking to save money by claiming their engines are so well designed that it can handle the "blowback" without any scientifically measurable effect on the engine through it's rated life (about 200k miles). On the other hand, you have the Catch Can manufacturers who point out excessive amounts of oil being pushed back into the engine and make it clear that oil is not designed to be combusted by the engine cycle (and therefore must result in some sort of long term negative effects that the engine manufacturers are denying).
In order to get to the real truth, someone needs to be willing to invest millions in unbiased 3rd party research, but as it turns out that isn't profitable for anyone so it just isn't going to happen.