Dewey
Spends too much time on here
Did you remove the steel bracket underneath? Some videos I watched they didn’t but imagine that would make it much easier.The starter went out on my 2021 Ram back in May. It was the same thing - one click and then nothing. I picked up a remanufactured starter from one of the chain part stores for $215 or so because the two dealerships near me didn't have any OEM starters in stock.
The new starter has been just fine. However, removing and installing the bottom starter bolt sucks. You have to chain together several socket extensions of varying sizes and at least one socket joint to bend around everything. My socket at that point was about 1.5ft long but it finally worked.
Good luck with replacing your starter.
Just picked up my new starter and installing later this afternoon.