Heres a question for ya.....
Why do truck manufacturers use a channel type beam under a truck that can hold mud and stuff? Wouldn't it be smarter to use Steel square stock or box beam construction? Inquiring minds....
Solid square stock of an equal weight will not have the same strength in the desired directions as formed metal.
Fully enclosed rails would be super strong in most directions, but be nigh impossible to coat for rustproofing.
partially enclosed rails would still ultimately accumulate garbage, and then cleanout would be a major hassle.
partially enclosed, fully coated/treated rails with an easy access cleanout/drain plugging of all the openings would be ideal, but then it comes back around to
COST.