I pay right around $1200 ever six months for full coverage insurance on my RAM and my wife's Traverse, liability insurance on my kids school car and our 66 Dodge D100(really need to get collector car insurance for it), my homeowners insurance, and some personal property insurance for jewelry, guns, and computers. Have $300 collision, and $50 Comp deductible on auto insurance with rental car coverage for the Traverse and my RAM. $300k/$500k bodily injury, $100k property, $10k per pwrson medical, uninsured, and under insured coverage, as well as unlimited roadside assistance towing/labor coverage for the RAM and Traverse(which is zero deductible). Won't get I to boring details of homeowners insurance of Valuable Person al Property since you only want to talk auto insurance. I'd rather save my "rainy day" savings account balance for real emergencies, rather than high deductibles.Not every state requires insurance.
New Hampshire which is right next to me doesn't require auto insurance.
Also the increase of cost for at fault accidents isn't per insurance company it's per the registry and it's called steps. Comprehensive claims are per insurance company.
On average the cost increase of a single at fault accident here is $3,000-$5,000. If you can fix the damage and it costs under $3000 it's ALWAYS best to do so and not report it. My wife clipped the front of a parked shi**y car at the local supermarket and I ended up buying the kid she hit a new bumper and installing it for him. Costed me around $550 for the bumper, headlight, and new clips. There was no damage to her Acadia
You also state having your Traverse repaired from damage you caused it... That's called at fault...
I clearly must be missing something in this conversation. I'm paying $650 a year for full collision coverage on my 2022 Ram 1500 Crew Cab Limited with an MSRP of 80k for reference. My deductible is also set at $1000
Edit:forgot about the life insurance policy also covered under that 6 month premium cost.