My truck is a Bighorn 4x4 with the Off Road Package and 3:92 gears. I have the front lifted 2.5 inches and am running 35-12.50-18 Nitto Ridge Grappler tires. I got the 3:92's because I knew I wanted 35's and I will do some towing up to about 5500 pounds.
I know my truck is not broke in yet, but even with the factory wheels and tires the best I have ever seen on the instant fuel economy has been 18-19, and that is driving 50-55. At 70, it was showing instant mileage of 14-16. I filled up the other day and drove mostly two lane highway and a good bit on the interstate and the tank was averaging under 15. Now, with the larger tires my speedometer/odometer is off 8 percent, so I have to add that to my miles when I hand calculate the mileage.
Today, I had to drive to the airport in St. Louis to pick up a friend. Since gas is so much cheaper down there i went ahead and filled up even though I was only down to about 3/4 of a tank. The computer showed I was getting 14.8 MPG. Hand calculated it came out to 17.9. That is a HUGE difference, and yes I calculated it correctly.
I was really disappointed when watching my computer mileage, especially with how easy I was driving. Yea, I know the fuel is winter blend which has a big effect on mileage, and I know about fluids and operating temperatures, and the bigger tires, and..........but i was still a little disappointed. But, the fact that the computer was that far off, and now knowing it is much better than I thought, I am actually pretty happy right now.
Could it be better? Sure. But a full size, hemi powered truck, on 35's with 3:92's, I am actually pretty stoked with 17.9 MPG. Will it get better? I am sure it will.
Sorry about the rambling, but I am fairly pleased with my fuel economy all things considered.