2019 Laramie 1500 Goodyear Steadfast HT or Michelin Defender LTX M/s2

[Partyof5]

I have a 2019 Laramie. Suspension is all stock. 95% highway driving in New York, so four seasons with some snow. I am looking to replace my stock tires, Goodyear Fortitude 275/65-18 ( weighs 37 pounds). Two tires I'm considering are the Good Year Steadfast HT (42 pounds) or the Michelin Defender LTX M/S2 (50 pounds). These two tires have different load ratings, and the Michelin is a heavier tire, which will decrease my fuel mileage, I assume. From the reviews I have read, these are my choices.



Does anyone have either of these tires on their truck? If so, what are your thoughts?

 

[disarm]

I just put the Michelins on my '24 Limited about six weeks ago and no issues so far... smooth ride, quiet and good wet traction. I'll find out about winter/snow performance soon enough, but they're very well regarded tires on this forum and around the internet, so I'm not really concerned.

 

[Partyof5]

Thanks, Disarm. They are highly regarded. Tire Rack had a good article that included this tire recently. If you had stock tires prior, have you noticed a difference in fuel economy? The Michelins are about 50 pounds each, and the stock tires are usually lighter.

 

[CHeYeNNe71]

I'm not a GY fan myself. Def Michelins.

 

[Ratchet]

I've always had great experience and ride quality with the LTX's and also with the AT2's. LTX MS2's have served me well even when towing our camper. Avg 75K with no problems. But, they do NOT like wet grass. Mud, sand, and snow is fine. Not grass...

We do not get alot of snow down here, so I can't speak for that. We get ice and folks here already drive worse than they do north of here.

If you're that concerned about fuel mileage, know that Michelin does use rubber compounds that contribute to their tires having the least rolling resistance vs others. However, size, weight, body plys, etc also contribute to that whole equation as well.

I was sad that Michelin didn't offer the type of tread design I need for my current vehicle, so I opted for BFG instead. Owned by Michelin. Always made a great product so that's another one to consider.

Was in the automotive biz for 30+ years and I cringed every single time somebody actually considered purchasing Goodyear. We finally got away from selling them just due to warranty concerns, customer complaints, premature failures, etc.... Goodyear makes a great product as well, but just not for the passenger market.

 

[Partyof5]

Thanks Racchet, Good information.

 

[disarm]

If you had stock tires prior, have you noticed a difference in fuel economy? The Michelins are about 50 pounds each, and the stock tires are usually lighter.

I did have the stock 22” Pirelli Scorpions prior to this and can't say that I've noticed a significant difference in gas mileage...but my heavily-optioned Limited is a pretty heavy truck to begin with, so I'm starting with lower MPG than most.

 

[Einstein376]

I have Michelins on my 2019 and have been very happy with them for year around use here in Michigan. The tires were on sale at Costco and I was happy with their service. They offer free rotations also.

Jim

 

[Jako]

I have Michelins on my 2019 and have been very happy with them for year around use here in Michigan. The tires were on sale at Costco and I was happy with their service. They offer free rotations also.

Jim

Does the rotation go beyond the 5 year warranty?

1. This warranty is valid for 60 months from the date of purchase, or until the tire reaches 1.6 mm (2/32 of an inch) or less in remaining tread depth regardless of age, whichever occurs first. When a tire has 1.6 mm (2/32 of an inch) or less in tread depth, it is considered worn out and this warranty does not apply.

https://tires.costco.com/CostcoRoadHazardWarranty?lang=en-US

 

[Partyof5]

Here is a quick thought. Costco sells the Defender LTX M/S2 275/65R18/XL 116 T tire ( MSPN 09590).

Sam's club sells the LTX M/S2 LT275/65R18/E123/120S tire ( MSPN39974). This is a 10 ply tire.

Is the MSPN 09590 a discontinued tire? I can't find both tires on Michelin's website. I am thinking I should stay away from the LT tire, as the NON-LT tire would have a softer ride. Any thoughts you can share?