5thGenRams Forums

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Adaptive Cruise Contol

Rjhagner

Active Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2019
Messages
32
Reaction score
15
Is it true that gas mileage suffers when using ACC? I also see the owners manual states that ACC should not be used when towing....anyone know why that would be?

Thanks
 

Rototerrier

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2018
Messages
349
Reaction score
375
1) Gas Mileage suffers because ACC or any cruise control in general aggressively tries to maintain the speed you've selected. It doesn't handle the subtle things your right foot does when you speed up a little down a hill to not have to give more gas to go up the next hill. You do that naturally. It just tries to maintain the set speed and doesn't do anything to adapt to the terrain. The adaptive part makes it even crazier. Once it locks in on the vehicle in front of you, it aggressively tries to maintain that distance and will surge the throttle quite a bit if the vehicle in front of you drives like an idiot. You would adapt to that behavior and let off a little to maintain a distance without trying to keep things perfect. All these things will result in worse fuel mileage. Wifes Q7 has cruise control settings and you can adjust how aggressively it tries to maintain speed. On the least aggressive, it will swing +/- 5 mph which helps maintain good fuel economy. It's kinda weird though, so I don't do it. I leave it where it maintains, otherwise folks behind me will go nuts. No one likes those types of speed fluctuations, but that's what it takes to not kill mileage with cruise.

2) ACC with a trailer...I've done it and it works fine in a wide open environment. I would NEVER do it in traffic. ACC without a trailer will sometimes brake so late that the collision warning comes on. If you had a trailer, I suspect it might result in an actual crash. My wife's Audi Q7 has NEVER stopped so late that it triggers a collision warning. My truck has done this several times. The ACC software needs some work and, for that reason, you should never tow with it...and if you are an idiot like me that doesn't always follow directions, only do it when there's no traffic and you are paying attention and in a wide open section of interstate. I really do think it will kill someone pulling a trailer...especially if the trailer doesn't have brakes. The truck wouldn't be able to stop and will probably lock up trying not to rear end someone.
 
Last edited:

Rjhagner

Active Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2019
Messages
32
Reaction score
15
1) Gas Mileage suffers because ACC or any cruise control in general aggressively tries to maintain the speed you've selected. It doesn't handle the subtle things your right foot does when you speed up a little down a hill to not have to give more gas to go up the next hill. You do that naturally. It just tries to maintain the set speed and doesn't do anything to adapt to the terrain. The adaptive part makes it even crazier. Once it locks in on the vehicle in front of you, it aggressively tries to maintain that distance and will surge the throttle quite a bit if the vehicle in front of you drives like an idiot. You would adapt to that behavior and let off a little to maintain a distance without trying to keep things perfect. All these things will result in worse fuel mileage. Wifes Q7 has cruise control settings and you can adjust how aggressively it tries to maintain speed. On the least aggressive, it will swing +/- 5 mph which helps maintain good fuel economy. It's kinda weird though, so I don't do it. I leave it where it maintains, otherwise folks behind me will go nuts. No one likes those types of speed fluctuations, but that's what it takes to not kill mileage with cruise.

2) ACC with a trailer...I've done it and it works fine in a wide open environment. I would NEVER do it in traffic. ACC without a trailer will sometimes brake so late that the collision warning comes on. If you had a trailer, I suspect it might result in an actual crash. My wife's Audi Q7 has NEVER stopped so late that it triggers a collision warning. My truck has done this several times. The ACC software needs some work and, for that reason, you should never tow with it...and if you are an idiot like me that doesn't always follow directions, only do it when there's no traffic and you are paying attention and in a wide open section of interstate. I really do think it will kill someone pulling a trailer...especially if the trailer doesn't have brakes. The truck wouldn't be able to stop and will probably lock up trying not to rear end someone.
Thank you Rototerrier for the excellent explanation! It is much appreciated.

As much as I enjoy ACC, I may use it a bit less frequently in an attempt to save mpg. Regarding towing my camper, I’ll stick with regular cruise control when the road allows it.
 

Johnvan

Active Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2019
Messages
109
Reaction score
96
I used it a bit while towing. The problem was on steep downgrades. I couldn't tell if it was riding the brakes so I stopped using it when going downhill. Regular cruise is fine downhill, it down shifts and doesn't brake.
 

SpeedyV

Ram Connoisseur
Staff member
Site Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2018
Messages
5,102
Reaction score
4,773
Location
Fort Worth, Texas
1) Gas Mileage suffers because ACC or any cruise control in general aggressively tries to maintain the speed you've selected. It doesn't handle the subtle things your right foot does when you speed up a little down a hill to not have to give more gas to go up the next hill. You do that naturally. It just tries to maintain the set speed and doesn't do anything to adapt to the terrain. The adaptive part makes it even crazier. Once it locks in on the vehicle in front of you, it aggressively tries to maintain that distance and will surge the throttle quite a bit if the vehicle in front of you drives like an idiot. You would adapt to that behavior and let off a little to maintain a distance without trying to keep things perfect. All these things will result in worse fuel mileage. Wifes Q7 has cruise control settings and you can adjust how aggressively it tries to maintain speed. On the least aggressive, it will swing +/- 5 mph which helps maintain good fuel economy. It's kinda weird though, so I don't do it. I leave it where it maintains, otherwise folks behind me will go nuts. No one likes those types of speed fluctuations, but that's what it takes to not kill mileage with cruise.

2) ACC with a trailer...I've done it and it works fine in a wide open environment. I would NEVER do it in traffic. ACC without a trailer will sometimes brake so late that the collision warning comes on. If you had a trailer, I suspect it might result in an actual crash. My wife's Audi Q7 has NEVER stopped so late that it triggers a collision warning. My truck has done this several times. The ACC software needs some work and, for that reason, you should never tow with it...and if you are an idiot like me that doesn't always follow directions, only do it when there's no traffic and you are paying attention and in a wide open section of interstate. I really do think it will kill someone pulling a trailer...especially if the trailer doesn't have brakes. The truck wouldn't be able to stop and will probably lock up trying not to rear end someone.
If it’s braking that late on you, you’re likely either (1) not setting it to leave enough car lengths between you and the vehicle in front of you, or (2) using the ACC in situations where traffic comes to a complete stop far enough ahead that your radar hasn’t picked up on the slowdown. Either way, that can be dangerous, as the system can only compensate so much.

That said, I completely agree about trailering. Drivers with trailers need to be decelerating and/or braking well in advance of the distances ACC would activate.
 

Rototerrier

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2018
Messages
349
Reaction score
375
If it’s braking that late on you, you’re likely either (1) not setting it to leave enough car lengths between you and the vehicle in front of you, or (2) using the ACC in situations where traffic comes to a complete stop far enough ahead that your radar hasn’t picked up on the slowdown. Either way, that can be dangerous, as the system can only compensate so much.

That said, I completely agree about trailering. Drivers with trailers need to be decelerating and/or braking well in advance of the distances ACC would activate.
I'm not the only one. This forum has many examples of folks having the same late braking acc tendencies. Compared to BMW, Mercedes, Audi, and even my old 2017 Honda CR-V, the acc on this truck suck big sweaty gonads. And that's just the gods honest truth.
 

Gondul

Ram Guru
Joined
Oct 9, 2018
Messages
835
Reaction score
645
Location
Florida
The ACC isn't anywhere near as smooth and seamless as the system on the wife's Fozzie...
 

Han Ridge

Active Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2018
Messages
44
Reaction score
38
I recently returned from a 5000 mile trip with a 6000lbs TT. ACC had little effect on flat highway but once you hit hills it did effect mileage. ACC does not take advantage of momentum gained on down hill runs. One thing I did a lot is to find a big rig doing my same speed and pull in behind it which cuts a lot of air. I saw as much as a 1.5 mpg gain doing this.
 

jeffmc306

Active Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2019
Messages
32
Reaction score
39
I wonder if anything has changed on the 2019 HD 2500's because they state on the website's "Safety & Security" tab that Adaptive Cruise works "even with a trailer attached". It also has the same wording under Forward Collision Warning with Active Braking.


Makes you wonder if the Marketing guys are making this stuff up or did the engineers improve the systems so they're compatible with a trailer? I'm upgrading from a '19 Ram 1500 and would really like to know! Gondul, what do you think?
Screen Shot 2019-05-21 at 7.11.13 AM.png
 

Gondul

Ram Guru
Joined
Oct 9, 2018
Messages
835
Reaction score
645
Location
Florida
The 2500 is at the dealer and I can't pick it up until Saturday!

I if the ACC is anything like the 1500 then you are probably ok if you are on a long, flat, straight section of road, I just find the system to be a little too abrupt for my liking.

Yeah, there were several things 'promised' that are have been delayed, like the AUX camera hookup and the TTPMS. Someone ordered the AUX Camera stuff from MOPAR and he says he received a ship notification... now to see if it is an easy install, or it will need to be taken to the dealer.
 

jeffmc306

Active Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2019
Messages
32
Reaction score
39
The 2500 is at the dealer and I can't pick it up until Saturday!

I if the ACC is anything like the 1500 then you are probably ok if you are on a long, flat, straight section of road, I just find the system to be a little too abrupt for my liking.

Yeah, there were several things 'promised' that are have been delayed, like the AUX camera hookup and the TTPMS. Someone ordered the AUX Camera stuff from MOPAR and he says he received a ship notification... now to see if it is an easy install, or it will need to be taken to the dealer.
That’s great news about your truck! Saturday is just around the corner :cool: We expect a full photo gallery over on the HD Forum!
I’m still waiting to hear from my salesperson on the status of a ‘19 Ram 2500 at another dealer in Milwaukee so fingers crossed.
 

Jello0123

Active Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2018
Messages
46
Reaction score
25
I noticed that if you turn on the ACC while towing it automatically adjusts to the farthest away setting for the vehicle in front of you. This is a nice safety feature since we do need more distance to slow down. I haven't used it much while towing but it is definitely better than "regular" cruise control.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top